Logging in Clojure / JVM – Part 3

In part 1 and 2, we looked at the history of logging and how to use SLF4J (a library I’m using with Zolodeck). In this part, we’re going to learn about different formats that we can use to log things in. We need to choose a correct log format so we can then get insights from our logs when we want them. If we cannot easily process the logs to get at the insights we need, then it doesn’t matter what logging framework we use and how many gigabytes of logs we collect everyday.

Purpose of logs:

  • Debugging issues
  • Historic analysis
  • Business and Operational Analysis

If the logs are not adequate for these purposes, it means we’re doing something wrong. Unfortunately, I’ve seen this happen on many projects.

Consumer of logs:

Before we look into what format to log in, we need to know who is going to consume our logs for insights. Most logging implementations assume that humans will be consuming log statements. So they’re essentially formatted string (think printf) so that humans can easily read them. In these situations,  what we’re really doing is creating too much log data for humans to consume to get any particularly useful insights. People then try to solve this overload problem by being cautious about what they log, the idea being that lesser information will be easier for humans to handle. Unfortunately, we can’t know beforehand what information we may need to debug an issue. What always ends up happening is that some important piece of information is missed out.

Remember how we can program machines to consume lots of data and provide better insights? So instead of creating log files for humans to consume, we need to create them for machines.

Format of logs:

Now that we know that machines are will be consuming our logs, we need to make a decision what format our logs should be in. Optimizing for machine readability makes sense, of course.

Formatted strings:

We can easily write a program using regex to parse our formatted strings log messages. Formatted strings, however, are still not a good fit, because of these following reasons:

  • Logging Java stack traces can break our parser thanks to new line characters
  • Developers can’t remove or add fields without breaking the parser.

What is a better way then?

JSON Objects:

JSON objects aren’t particularly human readable, but machines love them. We can use any JSON library to parse our logs. Developers can add and remove fields, our parser will still work fine. We can also log Java stacktraces without breaking our parser by just treating it as a field of data.

JSON log object fields:

Now that it makes sense to use JSON objects as logs, the question is  what basic fields ought to be included. Obviously, this will depend on the application and business requirements. But at a minimum, we’d need the following fields:

  • Host
  • Message
  • Timestamp
  • Log Level
  • Module / Facility
  • File
  • Line Number
  • Trace ID
  • Environment

Standard JSON log format:

Instead of coming up with a custom JSON log format, we ought to just use a standard JSON log format. One option is to use GELF, which is used by many log analysis tools. GELF stands for Graylog Extended Log Format. There are lot of open source log appenders that create logs in GELF format. I’m using it on my side project Zolodeck, and we use logback-gelf.

In this part of this blog series, we learnt why we need to think about machine readable logs, and why we ought to use JSON as the log format. In the next part, we will look at how to get insights from logs, using a bunch of open source tools.

3 thoughts on “Logging in Clojure / JVM – Part 3

  1. Pingback: Logging in Clojure / JVM – Part 4 | Zolo Labs

  2. Pingback: Logging in Clojure / JVM – Part 4 | Tech behind Tech

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s